My GSD loves these classic crunchy treats. He started with the puppy Milk Bones and now he's in the large dog Milk Bones. Of all the kind of treats that he gets, these seem to be his favorite. We make a presentation with them when he gets one and we spell out the name of the cookie and show him including the heart. Then he takes it to his bed and takes bites of it-- he actually chews which I know is great for his teeth. It's a quality product that we can trust. This big box is a great deal too!